| Team | Bid | Player | Bid Time | Removed | Active |
| Chattanooga Aramoho Titans | $800,000 | Travon Aviles | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Miami Yankees | $1,100,000 | Bartoli Romero | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Anaheim Blue Jays | $9,600,000 | Alijah Amaya | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Virginia Beach jimmies | $800,000 | Neal Roybal | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $1,600,000 | Rodrigo Valladares | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| $1,100,000 | Allen Bunn | 9 years ago | Yes | ||
| Knoxville Sluggers | $2,500,000 | Roman Dodson | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Baltimore Orioles | $7,300,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford HTFD_YANKEES | $9,500,000 | Alijah Amaya | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Columbus Troopers | $1,600,000 | Simon Wilcox | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Baton Rouge Red Sticks | $1,200,000 | Dario Correa | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $5,800,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| $1,600,000 | Oscar Hamlin | 9 years ago | Yes | ||
| Phoenix FooFighters | $1,600,000 | Simon Wilcox | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $15,000,000 | Donovan Foss | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Baltimore Orioles | $7,200,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Anaheim Blue Jays | $8,000,000 | Alijah Amaya | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Hartford HTFD_YANKEES | $66,600,000 | Jordon Macdonald | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $2,400,000 | Roman Dodson | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Columbus Troopers | $1,500,000 | Simon Wilcox | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Miami Yankees | $1,100,000 | Dario Correa | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Huntington Beach Braves | $900,000 | Jan Upton | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Austin Apaches | $2,100,000 | Deon Hulsey | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $7,100,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $5,500,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Knoxville Sluggers | $2,100,000 | Roman Dodson | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Baton Rouge Red Sticks | $800,000 | Jan Upton | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Lowell Rippers | $2,600,000 | Adolfo Liddell | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Baltimore Orioles | $7,000,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| McAllen Puppetmaster | $700,000 | Zachery Contreras | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Baton Rouge Red Sticks | $1,000,000 | Dario Correa | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Miami Yankees | $1,600,000 | Derick Ballou | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Green Bay Brewers | $3,500,000 | Alec Spillman | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Austin Apaches | $1,000,000 | Allen Bunn | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $4,800,000 | Buster Posey | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Spokane Warriors | $2,200,000 | Malakai Sheffield | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Miami Yankees | $900,000 | Dario Correa | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $5,100,000 | Jaeden Stevens | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| New Orleans Voodoo | $600,000 | Ahmad Banks | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $7,900,000 | Alijah Amaya | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| $600,000 | Guadalupe Murillo | 9 years ago | Yes | ||
| Anaheim Blue Jays | $7,800,000 | Alijah Amaya | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Phoenix FooFighters | $1,000,000 | Bartoli Romero | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| New Orleans Rusty Tollers | $1,000,000 | Honoria Quinonez | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Ann Arbor Wolves | $700,000 | Derrick Withers | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Miami Yankees | $1,700,000 | Moises Noriega | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $4,900,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $12,000,000 | Donovan Foss | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Phoenix FooFighters | $700,000 | Bartoli Romero | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $4,000,000 | Brenden Toney | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $1,200,000 | Moises Cavazos | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Phoenix FooFighters | $1,500,000 | Derick Ballou | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $1,500,000 | Rodrigo Valladares | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $5,000,000 | Dontae Cummins | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $11,100,000 | Donovan Foss | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Miami Yankees | $1,300,000 | Derick Ballou | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $3,600,000 | Brenden Toney | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| $900,000 | Allen Bunn | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No | |
| Miami Yankees | $1,300,000 | Roy Vandyke | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Baton Rouge Red Sticks | $4,600,000 | Dontae Cummins | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Louisville Colonels | $4,500,000 | Dontae Cummins | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Huntington Beach Braves | $400,000 | Nathen Sheets | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Baton Rouge Red Sticks | $4,200,000 | Dontae Cummins | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| $900,000 | Gunnar Romero | 9 years ago | Yes | ||
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $2,000,000 | Roman Dodson | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Hartford HTFD_YANKEES | $3,500,000 | Renato Adorno | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $1,100,000 | Jaime Anders | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $600,000 | Moises Cavazos | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $11,000,000 | Donovan Foss | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $800,000 | Rodrigo Valladares | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| New Orleans Voodoo | $3,000,000 | Finn Macmillan | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Miami Yankees | $700,000 | Neal Roybal | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Shreveport Ratchets | $700,000 | Florentino Sauceda | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford HTFD_YANKEES | $3,500,000 | Stephen Keaton | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $10,000,000 | Donovan Foss | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Miami Yankees | $700,000 | Travon Aviles | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Phoenix FooFighters | $800,000 | Finn Macmillan | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $4,100,000 | Dontae Cummins | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Manchester Batting Maniacs | $800,000 | Renato Adorno | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| New Orleans Voodoo | $5,000,000 | Jaeden Stevens | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Miami Yankees | $600,000 | Korey Comstock | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Charlotte Glazed Donuts | $700,000 | Rodrigo Valladares | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $7,500,000 | Donovan Foss | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| New Orleans Voodoo | $700,000 | Finn Macmillan | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Baton Rouge Red Sticks | $3,600,000 | Dontae Cummins | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $3,500,000 | Brenden Toney | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $7,100,000 | Donovan Foss | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $3,500,000 | Dontae Cummins | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $3,100,000 | Brenden Toney | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Phoenix FooFighters | $1,200,000 | Roy Vandyke | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| New Orleans Rusty Tollers | $800,000 | Stephen Keaton | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Phoenix FooFighters | $1,200,000 | Derick Ballou | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Baton Rouge Red Sticks | $3,100,000 | Dontae Cummins | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Ann Arbor Wolves | $700,000 | Cristian Tuttle | 9 years ago | Yes | |
| Knoxville Sluggers | $1,600,000 | Moises Noriega | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Miami Yankees | $1,100,000 | Roy Vandyke | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Calgary Fire Birds | $6,100,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $7,000,000 | Donovan Foss | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Miami Yankees | $1,100,000 | Derick Ballou | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |
| Louisville Colonels | $6,000,000 | Arnold Spillman | 9 years ago | 9 years ago | No |