| Team | Bid | Player | Bid Time | Removed | Active |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $400,000 | Sheldon Newsome | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $800,000 | Che Gaona | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $2,000,000 | Che Gaona | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Buffalo Centaurs | $700,000 | Chad Killian | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Buffalo Centaurs | $800,000 | Walker Casper | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Buffalo Centaurs | $700,000 | Silas Handy | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $400,000 | Yosef Larkin | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $500,000 | Che Gaona | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $400,000 | Micheal Cochran | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $400,000 | Aditya Hayward | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| $500,000 | Faro Saldivar | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| Philadelphia Phillies | $700,000 | Jeff Denman | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $600,000 | Silas Handy | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Enrique Torres | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $800,000 | Kristian Ingalls | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| $700,000 | Kristian Ingalls | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $600,000 | Jeff Denman | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $1,600,000 | Thaddeus Farnsworth | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| Philadelphia Phillies | $600,000 | Eliezer Hare | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Zayne Finnegan | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $500,000 | Jeff Denman | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Kirk Ramsay | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Detroit DeLuxury | $500,000 | Santino Winfield | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Brendon Vaughn | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $700,000 | Walker Casper | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $600,000 | Kristian Ingalls | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $600,000 | Jonas Santana | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| $600,000 | Chad Killian | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| Buffalo Centaurs | $500,000 | Chad Killian | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Buffalo Centaurs | $400,000 | Rahul Sandberg | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Buffalo Centaurs | $1,100,000 | Pablo Berger | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Buffalo Centaurs | $700,000 | Tristan Wilkes | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $400,000 | Kenny Montanez | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Seattle TheJimbopperinos | $500,000 | Eliezer Hare | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford Scamp | $500,000 | Ali Horan | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Pittsburgh Pittsburgh Rebel | $2,100,000 | Hortencia Samaniego | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Abilene Hookey | $500,000 | Jonas Santana | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $400,000 | Brock Labonte | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $1,900,000 | Tyrese Burrell | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $400,000 | Andres Ruvalcaba | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $400,000 | Alonso Foreman | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Hartford YANKEES_JK | $2,000,000 | Angelo Littleton | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Isiah Hays | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Jonas Santana | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $500,000 | Kristian Ingalls | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Madison Players | $2,000,000 | Hortencia Samaniego | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Austin Farmboys | $1,500,000 | Thaddeus Farnsworth | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Austin Farmboys | $600,000 | Tristan Wilkes | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Austin Farmboys | $600,000 | Tristan Wilkes | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Pittsburgh Pittsburgh Rebel | $1,600,000 | Hortencia Samaniego | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Buffalo Centaurs | $500,000 | Tristan Wilkes | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Buffalo Centaurs | $600,000 | Walker Casper | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| $500,000 | Mohammed Moran | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $2,000,000 | Reese Quillen | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $1,100,000 | Reese Quillen | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| Madison Players | $1,500,000 | Hortencia Samaniego | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Austin Farmboys | $1,000,000 | Semaj Mccullough | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Waco Hit & Run | $500,000 | Earl Stevens | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| $1,000,000 | Reese Quillen | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No | |
| $1,100,000 | Thaddeus Farnsworth | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No | |
| $500,000 | Reese Quillen | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No | |
| $600,000 | Jon Mason | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $1,000,000 | Norman Wenger | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $1,000,000 | Platon Almanza | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| Tacoma Green Sox | $1,000,000 | Jaiden Gillette | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Arlington low Ballers | $400,000 | Bret Reeves | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Arlington low Ballers | $400,000 | Reilly Mares | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Arlington low Ballers | $400,000 | Samir Varner | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Arlington low Ballers | $400,000 | Roano Verdugo | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Arlington low Ballers | $400,000 | Mariano Zielinski | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $500,000 | Walker Casper | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Ean Lane | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Eliezer Hare | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Fred Noyes | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Semaj Mccullough | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $500,000 | Norman Wenger | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $500,000 | Platon Almanza | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $400,000 | Angelo Littleton | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $500,000 | Jon Mason | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Philadelphia Phillies | $500,000 | Pranav Manley | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Bellingham Bells | $400,000 | Alan Lewandowski | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Bellingham Bells | $400,000 | Frascuelo Reynoso | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Bellingham Bells | $400,000 | Luis Brandenburg | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Abilene Hookey | $1,000,000 | Thaddeus Farnsworth | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Waco Hit & Run | $400,000 | Pueblo Peralta | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Waco Hit & Run | $400,000 | Clarence Rainey | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Waco Hit & Run | $400,000 | Chase Ratcliff | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Waco Hit & Run | $400,000 | Jorden Talbert | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| $400,000 | Kristian Ingalls | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No | |
| $400,000 | Mason Foote | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $400,000 | Kevon Arredondo | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $2,000,000 | Gitana Lerma | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| Detroit DeLuxury | $700,000 | Gitana Lerma | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| $600,000 | Thaddeus Farnsworth | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No | |
| Cincinnati White Sox | $400,000 | Bembe Alba | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| $12,000,000 | River Clancy | 12 years ago | Yes | ||
| $400,000 | Gitana Lerma | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No | |
| Seattle Admins | $9,000,000 | River Clancy | 12 years ago | Yes | |
| Austin Farmboys | $400,000 | Tristan Wilkes | 12 years ago | 12 years ago | No |
| Austin Farmboys | $400,000 | Shawn Jewett | 12 years ago | Yes |